The Totonicapan massacre in Guatemala: 8 Mayan Quiche killed, 30 wounded

Photo from


Guatemala: the logic of impunity and a fundamental lack of democracy and rule of law

After the Army massacre, president (and former army general) Otto Pérez Molina said:

“We ask the people for a return to peace, or we will impose the peace.”

Guatemalan Foreign Minister Harold Caballeros said:

“[The killing of 8 people] is not something that we should make a big deal about.”

WHAT TO DO: See below
Also below: Reflection by Emilie Smith: Bad old days in the Guatemalan Highlands

Guatemalan Foreign Minister: Murdered indigenous protesters not something to ‘make a big deal about’

October 09, 2012

GUATEMALA CITY – United Nations diplomats and ambassadors from the United States, European Union and Israel on Tuesday criticized Guatemala’s use of soldiers in public security operations, following violent military repression of a protest last Thursday that left eight indigenous Guatemalans dead in the western region of the country.

Guatemalan Foreign Minister Harold Caballeros, who confirmed eight deaths instead of seven as originally reported, met with members of the international diplomatic corps to deliver an official report of the attack, which happened as members of the Guatemalan military broke up a protest in Totonicapán, 170 kilometers west of the capital.

“With sadness, I recognize that in some parts of the world eight deaths is a very big deal, but, although it sounds bad to say this, … every day we have double that number of deaths [from violence]. So, it’s not something that we should make a big deal about,” Caballeros told members of the news media.

According to the government’s Human Rights Office, soldiers opened fire on a group of thousands of indigenous protesters from the department of Totonicapán, who blocked a section of the Inter-American Highway to draw attention to increasing electricity rates and policies of the administration of President Otto Pérez Molina. […]

Bad old days in the Guatemalan Highlands

by Emilie Teresa Smith

Late afternoon and all night long last Thursday — October 4th — rain washed the blood down into culverts along the Inter-American highway that snakes through the Guatemalan mountains.  Eight Maya-K’iche’ community leaders, peasant farmers and students were dead or dying, 30 more injured — fired upon by government soldiers.

The protestors had been occupying the road all day in the cold, high summit called Alaska concerned about three things:  uncontrolled hikes in rates by the now-privatized electrical company, a total transformation in the educational process for new teachers (making it much harder for poor and rural students to graduate), and complete lack of consultation by the national government around proposed constitutional reforms – changes that would have a tremendous impact on community governance, and control over their territories.

Violence by government troops is nothing new in these lands, or to those on whom this violence has been inflicted – Guatemala’s majority Maya-indigenous people.  Our hemisphere’s greatest blood-shedding occurred in the 1980s when government troops fanned out and killed a quarter-million people.  Memory of the war is still fresh-though often unspoken – in most people’s minds.

And the causes of the war still mark the country:  extreme poverty and marginalization of indigenous people, wildly unbalanced distribution of arable land, imposition from outside economic powers, there to squeeze a buck any-which-way out of these rich lands — from the original invaders, Spaniards out to get gold, then coffee barons of the 19th century, gringo banana barons of the 20th, and finally, Canadian mining companies seeking gold – again — in the 21rst.

When General Otto Perez Molina won the elections last year, and when he took office in January, no one really knew what to expect.  How could it get any worse?  More than 200 bus drivers a year getting killed, extortion on a grand scale, sky-rocketing drug violence, ever more women murdered — 6,500 average dead a year.  Perez Molina promised  ‘Mano Dura’.  An Iron Fist.

The Iron Fist has arrived.

The whole countryside – especially in zones of social conflict — has become a renewed military zone.  Five new bases have been opened since January, ostensibly to fight drug crime, but much of the focus has been on controlling community protest – which focuses mainly on protection of indigenous territories from foreign mega-projects.  The first large military action was in Cunen, in the war-scarred department of Quiché.  Next, military bases were imposed on two high-conflict areas – Chajul, Quiché and San Juan, Sacatepequez, where hydro-electric and cement factory projects have been sites of energetic community protest for years.  In May trouble erupted in Barrillas, Huehuetenango, over a proposed Spanish hydro-electric project, which community leaders claim, was imposed on them without proper consultation.  One man was killed during clashes with government security forces, and Perez Molina promptly imposed martial law on the region.  Several dozen community leaders are still in jail.

And on Thursday — Totonicapan.  With unimaginable deadly force, the peaceful blockade along the highway was attacked.

The united 48 villages of the department Totonicapan are among the best organized among the Maya in Guatemala.  Totonicapenses consider themselves the descendants of Atanasio Tzul, the great Maya-K’iche’ leader who in the first decades of the 19th century, successfully fought the Spanish colonial church and government. Totonicapan has ever been a guarding place for traditional ways.  This is evident in the rotating forms of leadership which maintain territory and practice authority despite the ravages of war, genocide and environmental attacks.  Passing through Toto — all of a sudden – there are trees, more trees, and white, clear rivers.  The forest guardians walk through these woods, and there isn’t a whiff of the Canadian mining invasion, so present elsewhere in the country.

On Saturday, October 6th, the town square of Totonicapan, and all the streets leading to it were crammed with mourners, and with protesters, determined not to stand down.  On Friday, October 12, as Columbus Day is marked up and down the continent, students, indigenous leaders, and peasant farmers from all of the Western Highland departments of Guatemala, have promised to fill every town square.  Isabel Yax, community leader from Toto says it in a few words, “Government troops or no, the conquest here has failed.”

[Emilie Teresa Smith (, a Canadian Anglican priest, writer and community activist, has worked for almost 30 years with Guatemala.  She lives in Santa Cruz del Quiché, department of Quiché, Guatemala.]



As distressful and painful as this latest massacre is, it is not surprising, it is not an anomaly.

The US and Canadian governments and North American resource extraction companies and investors maintain full and profitable economic and military relations with the undemocratic Guatemalan regime, elites and armed forces, always turning a blind eye to repression, violence and impunity that are the norm in Guatemala.

Please send copies of this information, and your own letters, to your own elected politicians (MPs, Congresspersons, Senators) and other government officials, and to your own media, demanding justice and reparations for the dead and wounded in this case, and asking why our governments actually do nothing about the on-going impunity, repression and violence, while promoting and benefiting from economic and military relations with the Guatemalan regime and economic elites.



make check payable to “Rights Action” and mail to:

UNITED STATES: Box 50887, Washington DC, 20091-0887

CANADA: (Box 552) 351 Queen St. E, Toronto ON, M5A-1T8

CREDIT-CARD DONATIONS can be made (in Canada and U.S.):

be a monthly credit card donor (Canada and U.S.)

to donate stock, contact:


Nov. 12-21, 2012 or Nov. 16-19, 2012.


March 16-23, 2013

Struggle for democracy, human rights, justice and the environment – versus – the illegitimate, military-backed Honduran regime and global companies and investors

Information: Grahame Russell, 1-860-352-2448,


  • SPEAKERS:  Contact us to plan educational presentations in your community

  • JOIN A DELEGATION:  Form your own group or join one of our delegation seminars to Guatemala and Honduras to learn first hand about community development, human rights and environmental struggles

  • DAILY NEWS: / / / / /

  • GOOD READING:  Eduardo Galeano “Open Veins of Latin America” / Howard Zinn “A People’s History of the United States” / James Loewen “Lies My Teacher Told Me” / Ronald Wright “Stolen Continents” / Naomi Klein “The Shock Doctrine” / Dr Seuss’s “Horton Hears A Who”



Grahame Russell



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.